• ⚠ Scheduled Maintenance — Friday, November 27
    This forum will be offline for annual maintenance beginning at approximately 8:00 AM Eastern on Friday, November 27. Service is expected to be restored by mid-to-late afternoon. We appreciate your patience.

Winterizing and smell from fresh water tank

Bruce O

Novice
I started to winterize my trailer today and as I was emptying the fresh water tank I noticed a slight smell.

The trailer unfortunately did not get used much this summer, but I always topped off the tank after each trip. BTW - I only use the tank water for washing pots/pans.

I was starting the winterizing process, opening the drain valve I noticed a smell and some black slime inside the tank near the removed the cap.

Should I address this issue now before I add the antifreeze or address the issue in the spring while preparing the trailer for the summer season?

I remember reading something about adding some bleach to the tank with water then driving around with the trailer to get the bleach mixture slashing around inside the tank. Is this the correct way to address this issue? If so, what ratio of bleach to water or are there better solutions?

Thanks.

Bruce
 
Update - I just read a recent post about sanitation of the tanks - so I filled the tank with water and a bit of bleach then drove around so it gets mixed in the tank. I'll wait 24 hours before I winterize. If anyone knows what the slime is please let me know.
Thanks,
Bruce
 
Update - I just read a recent post about sanitation of the tanks - so I filled the tank with water and a bit of bleach then drove around so it gets mixed in the tank. I'll wait 24 hours before I winterize. If anyone knows what the slime is please let me know.
Thanks,
Bruce
Bruce: Here's my routine: 30ml of 4.25% bleach per 8 gal, let sit 4hrs max. Bleach should be less than 1 year old as it can degrade, even if unused. Dilute in a gal of water before adding to tank as full-strength can damage plastic fittings/o-rings.

You may need a couple shots at this to get it back to usable. The black is biofilm. Stronger concentrations of bleach, although it may seem like a good idea, may actually be less effective and inhibit the sanitizing efficacy of the bleach; stick with the dilution formula. There is a basic chemistry explanation for this that escapes me at the moment. Antifreeze does not address the biofilm issue or sanitize the tank in any way.

Using city water with residual chlorine, when filling, may give you only several weeks of protection. After that all bets are off. If you are not planning another trip immediately, then drain after each outing.

I too only use the tank water for clean-up as it is difficult or impossible to keep the tank and all the nooks and crannies sanitized to the level where one can be confident about drinking it.
 
Here are the reasons why an overconcentrated household bleach is less effective at sanitizing:

1) when diluting, the pH shifts closer to neutral, which helps the active form of the chlorine sanitizing agent.

2) the high pH of concentrated bleach leads to corrosion of many materials (especially rubber gaskets and O-rings) over time. Surfaces can become brittle and/or porous and then tend to trap things, which is bad. The degraded surfaces even hang on to residual bleach, and rinsing them fully becomes a chore.

I have also heard that some biofilms can be more difficult to fully remove with concentrated bleach because the outer surface of the film gets killed quickly and becomes a sort of protective barrier that impedes the disinfectant can't get to the interior of the film.

My sanitization procedure for the fresh water tank follows the Camp-Inn User Manual (1 cup household bleach per tankful - the pre-dilution step mentioned by Steve and Karen is very helpful -- especially if one wants to avoid the hassle of driving around to agitate and mix the contents of the the tank).

If your problem is bigger than can be solved with a bleach treatment, you may have to resort to a specialized cleaning product. I have never needed this and so can't recommend how to do this, especially for the fresh water tank.
 
My sanitization procedure for the fresh water tank follows the Camp-Inn User Manual (1 cup household bleach per tankful
1) when diluting, the pH shifts closer to neutral, which helps the active form of the chlorine sanitizing agent.

6% bleach at this 1-cup concentration actually yields close to 500ppm, which is far greater than the recommended 50ppm for general disinfection, by most organizations tasked with establishing standards for water quality, treatment and mitigation (CDC, U of Minn and U of Maryland). You can "shock" it with a cup of bleach for a very short period at 500ppm, but I wouldn't leave it in for any longer than a couple hours. It will also require lots of flushing to bring the ppm down to something tolerable coming out of the tap. 500ppm also increases the risk of damage to components. The alkalinity at this concentration also rises well above a ph of 8, which reduces the overall effectiveness, as Turnip936 stated.

50ppm can safely be left in overnight, which may be a more effective strategy if indeed a protective film has formed over the biofilm, as Turnip936 has suggested could happen. 2ppm is the "maintenance level" to prevent bacteria and biofilm growth, and is certainly the level at which we can detect odour. Anything above 4ppm makes it undrinkable.

So those last 2 numbers give you a bit of a mental yardstick as to why 500ppm (or a full cup of regular bleach in a CampInn tank) is not a generally recommended approach, despite what the manual may say.
 
My AI overlord states 1/4 cup per 15 gal, so roughly 1/8 cup for 8 gal. Put a bowl in the sink and run the faucet and sprayer to get the solution through them too.

Then shake the camper like a crazed neanderthal to stir it up, let it sit overnight, then drain and rinse. Agree the manual has that formula a bit too strong.

If it's a bigger job, RV stores and Amazon sell a water heater cleaning wand that you connect to your garden hose. Shove it up the drain hole and go to town, then use a bore scope or endoscope to look around in there and make sure you got the gunk out.
 
Last edited:
"Overlord" indeed. Trust but verify.

And I definitely wasn't sitting here with a 1992 Texas Instruments calculator in hand when I came up with numbers.

BTW that 50ppm is also backed up by most reputable RV associations.

Bleach concentrations can vary wildly from manufacturer to manufacturer, and product to product, by as much as 100% So it's best to do the ppm math after you buy, with your Overlord sitting by your side, rather than relying strictly on quantity of liquid. But 100ppm isn't going to abjectly fail, or cause issues down the line, vs 50ppm.

That part of the C-I manual was likely compiled at a distant time when access to this type of accurate and verifiable information wasn't as easy, and the manual simply/probably hasn't been updated in the meantime to reflect best practices.

I don't travel without a paper and digital copy of the manual; it's far more comprehensive and useful than any owner of any type of trailer has a right to expect, and it's saved my bacon in a few instances. But on this particular thing, it's wrong.
 
If you don't use water, nor camp that much, doing a full drain might not be a bad idea...stagnant water does funky things....I experienced a little bit of that this past summer as I had a little over 2 months where it just sat. I'll be draining my tank when I put Serenity up for a long winters nap. Hopefully 1 or 2 more trips between now and then !!!
 
Wow - thanks for all the replies.

I did the 1/8 cup mixed with water and filled the tank, drove around on curvy / hilly roads, let it sit for about 3.5 hours then drained and filled/drained again. No bleach or funky smells. Then poured the pink RV stuff in and put it to bed for the winter.
 
Thanks to Steve and Karen and this thread, I am changing my disinfection procedure. After verifying the guidance from the CDC and the Univ of Minnesota, I am going to a 50-100 ppm concentration for a longer duration.

I think I have gotten away with the 500 ppm shock treatment because I have never left the bleach solution in the tanks for more than an hour or so. But I see no good reason to put up with the higher corrosive danger (to trailer components and my clothing) and the increased burden of rinsing.

I am constantly reminded of the tremendous value of this forum and its members.
 
I'm curious how commercial products like "Starsan" would work -- these are used very commonly in beer making to sanitize the equipment before bottling
 
I use Sterimine which is used in restaurant kitchens.
Starsan has a few advantages.

1] In foams so I suspect it gets into places that might otherwise not get coverage
2] Its no-rinse, just dump it and its ready to fill
3] It doesn't leave any taste...

But it offers no detergent action -- its just acidic.

Sterimine has to completely air dry before it is effective, which is its biggest disadvanage. Getting a tank dry is difficult at best.

BUT, I can tell you heatlh departments love the stuff!


I've been talking to friends and bleach seems to be the go-to. Along with detergent and agitation -- fill the tank half way, add some dawn and find a indiana road to travel on for a while....then rinse several times filling completely to get out as much soap as you can then rinse again and again. until the detergent is gone...then rinse pump, and plumbing...then bleach and rinse again. Unfortuantely there doesn't seem to be a magic bullet.
 
Back
Top